In the first year of business, you have literally no data for making decisions and predictions.
Even after the first hundred customers, half of those were serendipitous one-offs, not representative of repeatable, controllable customer acquisition, and the scale of the data isn’t statistically significant.
One of the root questions you have at the start, which is supposed to be data-driven (but you don’t have data) is: What’s the maximum I should bid for CPC (cost-per-click) campaigns like Google AdWords?
The answer for a funded startup is “Bid as much as possible, to get as many customers — and data! — as you can, as quickly as you can, then rapidly iterate from there in the presence of that data.”
Easy for them to say, but what about a bootstrapped, profit-driven business? Here you don’t have the budget to “spend as much as possible,” and you’re keen on getting a reasonable return on investment reasonably quickly, and you can’t just “spend to acquire the data.”
Here’s my way.
(Tune the exact numbers below if you disagree with my assumptions, but the process should be valid for anyone interested in chasing profits with a small budget.)
LTV = MRR x 20
MRR (Monthly Recurring Revenue) is the amount you charge a customer every month. Actually, it’s the average amount for all customers, which is typically a mixture of different quantities of customers at different tiers, special add-ons, etc..
LTV (Life-Time Value) is the total amount of money you expect to collect from a customer over their entire tenure with your company. In general you compute this as simply “MRR x [expected months]” meaning the average number of months a customer sticks with you. Some customers cancel in one month, some cancel in a year, some in five years, and some never cancel! So it can be difficult to compute LTV accurately for small companies, and impossible to know for young companies (where e.g. five years hasn’t elapsed yet to see exactly how many customer stuck it out that long).
If you do have data, here’s my deep dive on cancellation rates and LTV.
But since you don’t, in my experience (and in a non-scientific survey of some of the 100 startups currently officing at the fabulously Capital Factory co-working space in Austin), a good pre-data rule of thumb is 20 months.
If you have an average customer lifetime smaller than 20 months, that’s a dangerously high cancellation rate for almost any SaaS business, and you need to focus on addressing the business issues before focussing on acquiring more unsatisfied customers. Use surveys and one-on-ones to try to understand whether it’s technical failings, lack of features, missed expectations, bad service, doesn’t hit pain points, or what.
A healthy SaaS company will have a higher number of expected months, but at the start you also will have lots of mis-steps with early-adopters where your product is at its worst — least features, least quality, etc — so it’s good to assume a low LTV instead of inflating it to where it might be in future.
CAC = LTV / 5
CAC (Cost to Acquire a Customer) is your average total cost to get a new customer, which includes (as accountants say) direct costs (AdWords spend, affiliate payouts, the fees your affiliate system charges to process them) and indirect costs (consultants and your own time). So to compute CAC, take your total costs to acquire new customers and divide by the number of customers you acquired.
In general of course CAC needs to be less than LTV, otherwise it costs so much to get the customer that you can never make money. A surprising number of startups have CAC > LTV. Many justify this either by not correctly computing CAC (e.g. ignoring indirect costs) or saying they’ll “fix that later” by raising prices, finding other channels of revenue. Others justify by saying they’re doing a “land-grab” for customers, and just having a customer at all has intrinsic value.
Profit-seeking bootstrapped companies cannot afford those delusions. Also you need something far stronger than CAC = LTV, because you need to pay for other business expenses and still produce a profit. So how big can CAC be before it’s “too big?”
Growing, funded SaaS companies who treat CAC with respect often commonly target CAC = LTV / 3.
Back at my second startup IT WatchDogs, my co-founder Gerry Cullen used to say “A third to built it, a third to get rid of it, and a third to keep,” meaning a third of revenue goes to pay for hardware/inventory/shipping costs of the sale, a third goes to what I’m calling “CAC” here, and a third for the overhead costs, development costs, and profit.
That’s a good model, and I think a bootstrappped company can copy it, but I urge profit-seekers to instead adopt an even more strict model of CAC = LTV / 5. The reason is that at the start you should be able to find a few efficient ways of acquiring customers, even if those get saturated over time, because it’s exactly what you need early on when you have least-money, least-branding, and least-insight into marketing messages.
CAC = MRR x 4
If you combine the previous two results, you see that the cost to acquire a customer should be no more than four months of revenue.
Another good way to think about it is: “The payback-period for my cost to acquire a customer is four months.” Also, ideally you’re getting the first month of revenue back immediately, so it’s really three months of cash-float.
Companies with large budgets to deploy at scale will often be happy with 6-12 month payback periods; some very high volume businesses like shared hosting will accept 24 or 36 months even! But a bootstrapped company’s cash-flow won’t allow it, even if the math would work in the long run.
Conversion Rate = 1%
Conversion Rate is the percentage of visitors to your website who convert to a paying customer.
This is another step which in practice should be completely data-driven, segmented by customer type and marketing channel, segmented by landing page, A/B tested and iterated, blah blah blah. But since you don’t have data, and you don’t have enough visitors to have real ratios, you have to take a swag at this number.
In that same informal survey I ran, and bolstered by other formal surveys, a huge number of bootstrapped SaaS companies report a 1% conversion rate.
Another way of saying the same thing is “You need 100 visitors to make one sale.”
And since you need to incur no more than CAC dollars in the making of that sale, you need to incur no more than CAC/100 dollars in the making of each of those visitors.
And if you’re running a CPC campaign, that means you can pay up to CAC/100 dollars per click.
And since CAC is MRR x 4, we can substitute and get the end result:
CPC = MRR / 25
So for example if your average customer generates $50/mo, you can spend $2/click.
Indeed, this is a great way to prove one of my main arguments for all bootstrapped companies, which is that you should charge a lot more than you think, in part because it enables you to pay quite a lot per click, which enables a wide number of marketing channels, and out-bidding parsimonious competitors whose paltry LTVs preclude them from competitive marketing spend.
I know we’ll have lots of discussion in the comments, and I hope to see (good-natured) dissension and alternative ideas so that all of us get lots of perspective on how to do this sort of thing.
